We can probebly drag in SOMA here allso now that is a game that thought outside the box, underwater horro now that is probebly somthing that pushe the horro butten on a lot of pepole I mean, it was in flashbacks or whatever, but there were plenty of voices (I'm adding in the Amnesia mods, too).

I guess you are right in Amnesia having a more lonely feel, but Amnesia had people talking to you, too. I also like the characters more in the Penumbra series, in Amnesia they went more for a lonely feel (sure you are lonely in Penumbra also but you got some people talking to you attlist) But even then, I think Amnesia has a lot more to it. I've only watched him play either one or two of the Penumbra games. There are so many Amnesia mods I've watched Markiplier play. I think I like Amnesia more just because I've seen so much more gameplay of it than Penumbra. I do like Amnesia better than Penumbra, though.I mite just have nostalgia glasses on for Penumbra, but I find the whole atmosphere of dark abandoned mines and laboratory to be more creepy and unsettling than a old castle/mansion.

I remember watching Markiplier play both games.

Markiplier amnesia custom story